After reading both sides of the issue, I am more inclined to agree with Marcovitz. Children these days are so focused on their electronic toys they don’t look both ways before crossing the street anymore. They don’t even know that they are in the street. “We teach them facts and reward them with digital candy and then wonder why they can’t sit still to learn without that candy.” (Marcovitz, 2008)
I also believe that these digital kids are losing touch with the physical world. When John David Son asks us to “imagine a school with no library, no books-just computers,” I am horrified at the thought. (Son, 2008) We have already concluded that I am old-fashioned, so when I say I like the library I mean it! I love the hushed atmosphere and browsing through rows and rows of books. I love holding books and the swishing sound of paper on paper as I turn pages. The smell of ink as I take notes makes me feel productive.
Now I find myself wondering how technology will affect my classroom. When students can buy a program to help them write for a symphony how tempted will they be to endure the training to become a real musician or composer? If you have a computer playing all the other parts for you will you want to learn to play with a real group? In this plugged in era it can be all too easy to undervalue the fine art disciplines, and our cultural values are shifting toward instant gratification and quick fixes.
References
Marcovitz, D. M. & Son, J.D. (2008). Learning and Leading With Technology: Is Educational
Technology Shortening Students’ Attention Spans? International Society for Technology in Education.
Friday, July 31, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment